Re: Sarge -> Etch upgrade issue
On Sat, Sep 09, 2006 at 02:39:30PM +0200, Alexander Schmehl wrote:
> * Steve Langasek <email@example.com> [060908 20:36]:
> [ apt-get dist-upgrade to etch doesn't install debianrchive-keyring and
> gnupg ]
> > > Shouldn't the Recommends: debian-archive-keyring be enought? AFAIK
> > > the Release Notes recommend using aptitude instead of apt-get. And
> > > aptitude respects recommends should pull in debian-archive-keyring,
> > > which depends on gnupg.
> > Ah, good catch. (I wonder why apt has a separate Suggests: gnupg then?)
> > This means that users who dist-upgrade using aptitude, pulling in
> > Recommends, should not have this problem; so the most that should be needed
> > here is release notes documentation. Assuming someone can test that this
> > works as expected?
> Uhm... seems that I was to fast. I just did a small test (created a new
> sarge chroot, changed sources.list, tried a dist-upgrade), and even when
> using aptitude neither debian-archive-keyring nor gnupg are installed.
> While apt and apt-utils are upgraded, I get the following note from
> The following packages are RECOMMENDED but will NOT be installed:
> aptitude-doc-en debian-archive-keyring libtasn1-2-bin locales mtools
Ok, that was a possibility I had in mind; AIUI aptitude (frequently?
always?) ignores Recommends: when upgrading a package that's already
That leaves two solutions that I see:
- ask the apt maintainer to bump the d-a-k recommends to a depends
- document in the release notes the need to install d-a-k before
dist-upgrading, and document how to adjust /etc/apt/apt.conf if the user
has already skipped this step in error.
Like you, I prefer the first option.
Would someone please file a serious bug against apt for this?
Steve Langasek Give me a lever long enough and a Free OS
Debian Developer to set it on, and I can move the world.