On Wed, 23 Jun 2004 22:44:42 +0100 MJ Ray wrote: > I see. Were you absent from the discussion earlier this year about > whether these summaries would be useful? Now that we've seen them in > action a few times, I feel that they are doing more harm than good > because they always seem to include "this is a free licence" or "this > is a non-free licence". Too much is being focused on these binary > distinctions and the interesting part is whether the ITP'd or P'd > software is free or non-free, really. Well, it's true that the final judgement is on the freeness of software /packages/ (that's the primary activity of debian-legal, isn't it?). Anyway, IMHO, summaries of /license/ analyses are still useful. Those summaries, when collected together, form a sort of vademecum for a) someone willing to perform a first quick & rough freeness check on a newly discovered piece of software (a more accurate review could be needed, when someone actually willing to create a package is in doubt) b) someone willing to choose a free license avoiding the ones which are clearly non-free (those people would go and pick some OSI-approved or FSF-approved license, if no such Debian list of licenses existed... and realize that our criteria are different only when it's late) c) the author(s) of a reviewed license willing to fix the issues that debian-legal has with the license itself (without a list of license summaries, they could never find out that their license has something to be fixed) d) someone willing to know the conclusions of debian-legal discussions without having to actually follow *all* the long threads (debian-legal is often quite verbose, and many people are not interested *that much* in legal discussions, while they still need to know what has been concluded) Moreover the summaries are good references that avoid us to explain again and again why license L is clearly non-free. -- | GnuPG Key ID = DD6DFCF4 | You're compiling a program Francesco | Key fingerprint = | and, all of a sudden, boom! Poli | C979 F34B 27CE 5CD8 DC12 | -- from APT HOWTO, | 31B5 78F4 279B DD6D FCF4 | version 1.8.0
Attachment:
pgpqRdKSDn5gS.pgp
Description: PGP signature