Bug#1753: trn recommends, instead of depends
On Tue, 24 Oct 1995, Ian Jackson wrote:
> Bdale Garbee writes ("Bug#1753: trn recommends, instead of depends"):
> > Package: trn
> > Version: 3.6-2
> >
> > It's not clear to me why trn uses 'recommends' for a mail transport
> > and a news article injector, while tin uses 'depends'. I think that depends
> > makes more sense, so I'm filing this against trn.
>
> Recommends is correct. You can read news perfectly happily without
> either a mail transport or a news article injector.
>
> I'll reassign the bug report to tin.
Are you sure this is right? Normal functionality of tin allows the user
to mail a response or the article to an address. Would it be correct for
the system to allow someone to install a package where some of the
functionality is missing? This would surely generate another defect
report.
I suppose recommends is a strong enough relationship that the system
maintainer would realize that some functionality may be missing if a
recommended package is missing.
I will make the change to the tin package.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Kenny Wickstrom | gnu - a new generation in s/w devel/support
kenny@kennet.com | Linux - a much improved Un*x clone
(708)740-4008 | Debian - a Linux distribution setting the
#include <std-disclaimer> | standard for future distributions
Reply to: