[Date Prev][Date Next] [Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Bug#524235: Default alt-gr key replacement should be right alt for usa keyboard.



Quoting Kurt Roeckx (kurt@roeckx.be):

> The US international on windows uses dead keys, which is something
> I wouldn't want.  But such option is probably useful for some
> people.


I would very strongly advise against diverging from what's done in
other OS. The most common keyboard layouts are now standards in most
countries that define keyboard layouts and their behaviour and, when
they exist, they're implemented in these other OS (well, let's be
clear: in Windows).

Whether this is "good" or not is generally a matter of taste, but
having different behaviours is exactly what should be avoided,
imho. This is what lead to the current nightmare that is "implemented"
in console-data.

So, if US international in Windows uses dead keys, then US
international in X should use dead keys (it does, actually) and so
should do console-setup. Nothing prevents those people who want
something else to change settings or create their own variant.

To be clear: I *know* about consequences of the "dead tilde", no need
to give it to me as a counter-example.

But, please take this as a pledge: don't restart with X what was done
with console keymaps and create a big pile of crap that becomes
unmaintainable over time.


Attachment: signature.asc
Description: Digital signature


Reply to: