install documentation attribution/copyright in ubuntu & debian.
I've used other distros, today I decided to try out ubuntu and debian and I
noticed something that doesn't seem right. I was reading the install
documentation and decided to compare with ubuntu. I first noticed that this page
http://www.debian.org/releases/stable/amd64/ch04s03.html.en
was almost the same as this page
https://help.ubuntu.com/8.10/installation-guide/amd64/boot-usb-files.html
Then I noticed that a lot of the debian and ubuntu install documentation seems
to be the exact same sentences.
Ok, thats fine, but then I noticed that the debian install doc is copyrighted
gplv2 and ubuntu one is copyrighted as Creative Commons ShareAlike 3.0 License.
From what I've read, you can't relicense a derived work either way with these
licenses without the original authors permission.
So then I looked at the documents and debian's says copyright by "Debian
Installer team". Ubuntu's says it is "maintained by the Ubuntu documentation
team" and has a list peoples names of contributors. Hmmm...
Regardless of any copyright issue, it doesn't seem right or accurate that I'm
reading the exact same sentences of documentation on the ubuntu site as the
debian site, and both sites have listed copyright holders/contributors that
absolutely nothing in common with each other.
- Ian
Reply to: